← Back to case files
Case File · Oversight & Records RELATED TO FILE NO. 014 & FILE NO. 022

Moore v. City and County of San Francisco

Class action complaint — U.S. District Court, Northern District of California
Docket: 3:25-cv-11011 Filed: Dec. 28, 2025 Voluntarily dismissed: Jan. 28, 2026 Judge: Sallie Kim

San Francisco resident Michael Moore filed a putative class action against the City and County of San Francisco, the San Francisco Police Department, and the department's former interim chief, targeting SFPD's network of more than 450 Flock Safety automated license-plate reader cameras.

What the complaint alleged

The complaint described a citywide system that photographs and tracks the movements of essentially every passing vehicle, feeding an AI-assisted database that SFPD officers could search without a warrant. It went further than a pure Fourth Amendment theory, though: it alleged that ALPR data had been shared with out-of-state law enforcement, including at least 19 searches tied to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, in violation of California's Senate Bill 34 — the state law restricting ALPR data sharing outside California. The plaintiff sought class certification, a court order halting the camera program and deleting collected data, and attorneys' fees.

How it ended

Unlike the Norfolk case, this one never reached a ruling on the merits. The plaintiff amended the complaint in January 2026, then filed a notice of voluntary dismissal, and the case was closed on January 28, 2026 — about a month after it was filed. The docket doesn't explain the reason for the dismissal.

Why it's still useful

Even without a decision, the filings are a real-world template for how an ALPR-misuse claim gets pled, and they connect to a documented incident: around the same period, SFPD disclosed that an audit had found its Flock network "improperly queried" by an outside agency — the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center — prompting the department to cut off that agency's access. That audit and this lawsuit describe overlapping concerns about who, in practice, ends up able to search a city's plate-reader data.

Why it matters for File No. 014 & 022: This case is the clearest example on file of the access-rules problem in practice — a state law (SB 34) restricting out-of-state and federal sharing, alleged real-world violations of it, and a department response, all in one docket.

↓ View the full docket and filings (CourtListener / RECAP)
Primary sources