Two Norfolk, Virginia residents, Lee Schmidt and Crystal Arrington, sued the city and its police chief, arguing that Norfolk's network of 176 Flock Safety automated license-plate reader cameras amounts to warrantless mass surveillance in violation of the Fourth Amendment. Their attorneys, from the Institute for Justice, asked the court to declare the program unconstitutional and to order it stopped.
How the court framed the question
Judge Davis split the ALPR program into two stages: photographing and storing vehicle images ("Step One"), and an officer later querying that stored database for hits ("Step Two"). The plaintiffs had standing to challenge Step One, since their cars were undisputedly photographed hundreds of times, but not Step Two — their plates were never actually searched outside of the lawsuit itself.
Why the city won
On the merits, the court measured Norfolk's system against two controlling precedents: Carpenter v. United States, where the Supreme Court found that near-continuous cell-tower tracking of a suspect violated the Fourth Amendment, and Leaders of a Beautiful Struggle v. Baltimore Police Department, where the Fourth Circuit struck down an aerial-surveillance program that tracked nearly every person and vehicle in the city each day. The court found Norfolk's system fell well short of that scale: its cameras sit in only 75 fixed clusters across 66 square miles, and even the most-photographed plaintiffs were caught by a full match only two to three times a day on average, with miles and dozens of minutes typically separating hits. The court described the system as capturing locations, not people — closer to a scattering of static checkpoints than to an ankle monitor.
A narrow ruling, not a final word
The court was careful to say its ruling was tied to Norfolk's system as it exists today, not a blanket approval of ALPR technology generally. It noted that a denser or more persistent camera network could tip the constitutional balance the other way in a future case, and it pointed to a new Virginia statute — which cut Norfolk's data retention from 30 days to 21 and restricted sharing outside the state — as an example of legislatures, not just courts, setting guardrails. The plaintiffs are appealing to the Fourth Circuit, and the Electronic Privacy Information Center has since filed an amicus brief supporting them.
Why it matters for File No. 014 & 022: This is the most detailed judicial look yet at how big an ALPR network has to get, and how it's actually used, before courts will call it a "search" requiring a warrant — directly bearing on both the spread of these networks and the rules governing who can query them.